Pollution adjudication board

Water pollution has been happening since the beginning of human history. However, the pollutants that most people think of today mostly began after the Industrial Revolution and be...

Pollution adjudication board. 31 Pollution Adjudication Board Vs - Read online for free. CONSTITUTIONAL LAW DIGEST

G.R. No. 148267 August 8, 2002. SULU RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, respondent. Decisions and final orders of the Mines Adjudication Board (MAB) are appealable to the Court of Appeals under Rule 43 of the 1997 Rules of Court. Although not expressly included in the Rule, the MAB is …

Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVES, as it is hereby RESOLVED, to adopt the following guidelines in the interruption of periods in its processes, to wit: 1. These guidelines shall apply only to proceedings for cases pending before the Board for violations of Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, in areas where the Pollution Adjudication Board. Created under EO no. 192 (Administrative Code of 1987) reorganizing the DENR. The Pollution Adjudication Board is directly under the Office of the Secretary. The Board shall be composed of the Secretary as Chairman, two (2) Undersecretaries as maybe designated by the Secretary, the Director of the Environmental Management, and …Jul 19, 2022 · Maynilad Water Services, Inc. Vs. The Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (“DENR”), the Pollution Adjudication Baord (“PAB”), The Regional Executive Director, Environmental Management Bureau-National Capital Region (“EMB-NCR”), The Regional Director, Environmental Management Bureau-Region III (“EMB-Region III”), The Regional Director, Environmental ... – Provide secretariat support to the pollution adjudication board per EO 192 – Provide secretariat support to the National Solid Waste Management Commission as provided for in Section 4 of Ra 9003 – Develop and implement a research and development program in support of the following: Environmental …The Pollution Adjudication Board pursuant to its powers and functions under Section 19 of Executive Order No. 192, Series of 1987, RESOLVES as it is hereby RESOLVED to promulgate and adopt the following Revised Rules on Pleading, Practice and Procedure in the adjudication of pollution cases.Petitioners claim that they were denied due process when the Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources found them liable and imposed a penalty on them without the recommendation of the Pollution Adjudication Board, as required under Section 28 of Republic Act No. 9275. 1. Petitioners were sufficiently accorded due process.

(15) days from receipt of the Order of the Regional Office to the Pollution Adjudication Board, by virtue of which the PAB can now exercise appellate jurisdiction over the above-mentioned cases decided by the Regional Offices; WHEREFORE, the Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVED, AS IT ISIn Pollution Adjudication Board vs. Court of Appeals,30 we stated that the PAB is the very agency of the government with the task of determining whether the effluents of a particular industrial establishment comply with or violate applicable anti-pollution statutory and regulatory provisions.31 We also recognized its power to issue, ...2 days ago · Upon the recommendation of the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), anyone who commits prohibited acts such as discharging untreated wastewater into any water body will be fined for every day of violation, the amount of not less than Php 10,000 but not more than Php 200,000. Board Member, Pollution Adjudication Board Department of Environment and Natural Resource, Republic of the Philippines May 2004 - Hun 2016 12 (na) taon 2 (na) buwan. Quezon City, National Capital Region, Philippines Adjudication of nationwide pollution cases Edukasyon De La Salle University - Higit pang aktibidad ni (Anthony) Shun Fung ...Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) SC affirms P2.79M fine for Mandaluyong condo for untreated wastewater September 20, 2017 The Supreme Court (SC) has affirmed the P2.79-million fine imposed by the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) on Summit One Condominium Corporation (SOCC) for its failure to amply treat its wastewater.The National Ecosavers Program aims to develop, implement and install the sustainability mechanisms, and a strategic approach to Ecological Solid Waste Management in selected public elementary schools and high schools in Metro Manila. Day 1 Photo of the participants together with Day 2 Photo of the …The Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) is a bureau under the Department of Environment and Natural Resources that is responsible for formulating and implementing plans, programs, and standards for environmental protection and pollution prevention. Learn more about the EMB's mandate, functions, and …From doing your research before you leave, to getting a decent mask and fitting it properly, here’s how to protect yourself from air pollution while traveling. According to the Wor...

Jun 10, 1987 · Pollution Adjudication Board. There is hereby created a Pollution Adjudication Board under the Office of the Secretary. The Board shall be composed of the Secretary as Chairman, two (2) Undersecretaries as may be designated by the Secretary, the Director of Environmental Management, and three (3) others to be designated by the Secretary as members. Shell moved for dismissal of the complaint alleging that the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), not the trial court, has primary jurisdiction over pollution cases and actions for related damages and that it could not be sued pursuant to the doctrine of state immunity without the State’s consent on the basis that it merely …In this connection, it must be noted that in Pollution Adjudication Board v. Court of Appeals, et al ., 27 the Court ruled that the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) has the power to issue an ex-parte cease and desist order when there is prima facie evidence of an establishment exceeding the allowable standards set by the anti-pollution laws ...In Pollution Adjudication Board vs. Court of Appeals,[30] we stated that the PAB is the very agency of the government with the task of determining whether the effluents of a particular industrial establishment comply with or violate applicable anti-pollution statutory and regulatory provisions.[31]

Calendar schedule maker.

body en banc g.r. no. 202897, august 06, 2019 maynilad water services, inc., petitioner, vs. the secretary of the department of environment and natural resources ("denr"), the pollution adjudication board ("pab"), the regional executive director, environmental management bureau-national capital region ("emb-ncr"), the regional director, environmental management bureau …The Pollution Adjudication Board pursuant to its powers and functions under Section 19 of Executive Order No. 192, Series of 1987, RESOLVES as it is hereby RESOLVED to …National Water Quality Status Report CY 2001 – 2005. National Water Quality Status Report CY 2006 – 2013 . National Water Quality Status Report CY 2014 – 2019 G.R. No. 202897, August 6, 2019 Facts: On April 2, 2009, the Regional Office of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) Environmental Management Bureau-Region III (EMB-RIII) filed a complaint before the DENR's Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) charging MWSS and its concessionaires, Maynilad and Manila Water, with failure to provide, install, operate, and maintain… Pollution Adjudication Board v. CA, 195 SCRA 112. Facts: Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte cease and desist orders to Solar Textile Finishing Corp (Private Respondent) from utilizing its wastewater pollution source installations which were discharging untreated wastewater directly into a canal leading to the adjacent Tullahan …POLLUTION ADJUDICATION BOARD vs. COURT OF APPEALS and SOLAR TEXTILE FINISHING CORP. G.R. No. 215029, July 5, 2017 SUMMIT ONE CONDOMINIUM CORPORATION vs. POLLUTION ADJUDICATION BOARD Likewise, it is worth stressing that the courts generally accord great respect, if not finality, to factual

Most studies point to the fact that domestic wastewater is the principal cause of organic pollution (at 48%) of our water bodies. Yet, only 3% of investments in water supply and sanitation were going to sanitation and sewage treatment. ... Upon the recommendation of the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), anyone …The nine recognized types of pollution in the modern world are air pollution, water pollution, land pollution, noise pollution, radioactive pollution, thermal pollution, light poll...Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVES, as it is hereby RESOLVED, to adopt the following guidelines in the interruption of periods in its processes, to wit: 1. These guidelines shall apply only to proceedings for cases pending before the Board for violations of Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, in areas where the Pollution Adjudication Board - Free download as Powerpoint Presentation (.ppt / .pptx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or view presentation slides online. 1 Assailed in this Petition for Review on Certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court is the May 29, 2014 Decision [1] of the Court of Appeals (CA), in CA-G.R. SP No. 132046, which dismissed the Petition for Review [2] filed on October 2, 2013 and affirmed the Orders dated September 20, 2012 [3] and July 12, 2013 [4] both issued by respondent Pollution …Pollution Adjudication Board vs. CA, G.R. No. 93891, March 11, 1991 cc: Musa, Ricardo Jr Asani, Fatima Bonsucan, Elton John Santos, SoniaThe Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte order directing Solar Textile Finishing Corporation to cease and desist from discharging untreated wastewater into a canal leading to the Tullahan-Tinejeros River. The Court of Appeals reversed the order and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings.FACTS: On April 2, 2009, the Regional Office of the DENR Environmental Management Bureau-Region III (EMB-RIII) filed a complaint before the DENR’s Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) charging MWSS and its concessionaires, Maynilad and Manila Water, with failure to provide, install, operate, and maintain adequate Wastewater Treatment Facilities …Pollution Adjudication Board." In that Decision and Resolution, the Court of Appeals reversed an order of the Regional Trial Court, Quezon City, Branch 77, in Civil Case No. Q-89-2287 dismissing private respondent Solar Textile Finishing Corporation's ("Solar") petition for certiorari and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

Pollution Adjudication Board." In that Decision and Resolution, the Court of Appeals reversed an order of the Regional Trial Court, Quezon City, Branch 77, in Civil Case No. Q-89-2287 dismissing private respondent Solar Textile Finishing Corporation's ("Solar") petition for certiorari and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings.

Pollution Adjudication Board - Free download as Powerpoint Presentation (.ppt / .pptx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or view presentation slides online. 1The Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte order directing Solar Textile Finishing Corporation to cease discharging untreated wastewater from its plant. Solar filed a petition for certiorari against the order. The regional trial court dismissed the petition but the Court of Appeals reversed, declaring the writ of execution null and …WHEREFORE, the Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVED, AS IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED, that the following guidelines should be followed in the filing of an appeal on Orders by virtue of PAB Resolution No. 1 series of 2019, to wit: SECTION I. These guidelines shall be applicable for establishments andThe document discusses the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), which adjudicates pollution cases in the Philippines. The PAB has the power to issue orders requiring compliance with anti-pollution laws, impose fines and penalties, and enforce its decisions like a court. It is composed of DENR officials and handles …Jul 5, 2017 · This case involves a petition for review on certiorari filed by Summit One Condominium Corporation (SOCC) against the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) and the Environmental Management Bureau - National Capital Region (EMB-NCR). The PAB imposed a fine of PHP 2,790,000 on SOCC for its alleged... emb.gov.ph Jul 12, 2022 · The Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) has the exclusive and original jurisdiction with respect to adjudication of air and water pollution cases Quasi-judicial body created under Section 19 of Executive Order 192 for the adjudication of pollution cases Composition: DENR Secretary as the Chairman, 2 DENR Undersecretaries, EMB Director, 3 others Board Members _ EMB-Pollution Adjudication Board - Read online for free. The document lists the members of the Philippine Accreditation Board (PAB). Secretary Roy A. Cimatu is the Board Chairman. Other members include Undersecretaries Rodolfo C. Garcia and Jonas R. Leones who serve as Presiding Officer and Alternate Presiding Officer respectively.

Font spacing.

Nba live free stream.

– Provide secretariat support to the pollution adjudication board per EO 192 – Provide secretariat support to the National Solid Waste Management Commission as provided for in Section 4 of Ra 9003 – Develop and implement a research and development program in support of the following: Environmental …These Boards are mostly known as Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) at the National level and State Pollution Control Board (SPCB) at the State level. The primary objective of both the Boards is to provide for the prevention, control and abatement of pollution and Acts like these empower them with …Case digest by . Digest not created. You do not seem to have any annotations for this case.Creating your own digest is easy.On March 10, 2001, petitioner filed a complaint with the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) for the abatement of noise and/or pollution and damages, with a plea of injunctive relief.11 In a letter dated March 7, 2002, petitioner filed a complaint with then Makati City Mayor Jejomar C. Binay with prayer to cancel the Mayor's License and … Petitioner Pollution Adjudication Board ("Board") asks us to review the Decision and Resolution promulgated on 7 February 1990 and 10 May 1990, respectively, by the Court of Appeals in C.A. - G.R. No. SP 18821 entitled "Solar Textile Finishing Corporation v. Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVES, as it is hereby RESOLVED, to adopt the following guidelines in the interruption of periods in its processes, to wit: 1. These guidelines shall apply only to proceedings for cases pending before the Board for violations of Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, in areas where thePOLLUTION ADJUDICATION BOARD (PAB) The Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) is a quasi-judicial body created under Section 19 of Executive Order (E.O.) 192 for the adjudication of pollution cases. The Pollution Adjudication Board is created under the Office of the Secretary. The Board shall be composed of the …The National Ecosavers Program aims to develop, implement and install the sustainability mechanisms, and a strategic approach to Ecological Solid Waste Management in selected public elementary schools and high schools in Metro Manila. Day 1 Photo of the participants together with Day 2 Photo of the …Pollution Adjudication Board." In that Decision and Resolution, the Court of Appeals reversed an order of the Regional Trial Court, Quezon City, Branch 77, in Civil Case No. Q-89-2287 dismissing private respondent Solar Textile Finishing Corporation's ("Solar") petition for certiorari and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings.The Oregon small claims courts will hear and adjudicate claims against individuals or businesses for damages up to $10,000 For legal claims of up to $10,000 against another person ...SARIGUMBA_Summit One vs Pollution Adjudication Board - Read online for free. enviAir Quality Management; Water Quality Management; Chemical Management; Hazardous Waste Management; Philippine Ozone Desk; Pollution Adjudication Board; PCB and E-waste Management Project; Services. Issuances. Issuance of ECC for Category B Projects (Online) Issuance of ECC Amendment; … ….

- For actual exceedance of any pollution or air quality standards under this Act or its rules and regulations, the Department, through the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), shall impose a fine of not more than One hundred thousand pesos (P100,000.00) for every day of violation against the owner or operator of a stationary source until such ... Petitioners claim that they were denied due process when the Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources found them liable and imposed a penalty on them without the recommendation of the Pollution Adjudication Board, as required under Section 28 of Republic Act No. 9275. 1. Petitioners were sufficiently accorded due process.Dispute Boards By Peter H.J. Chapman1 What is a Dispute Board? A Dispute Board or DRB (Dispute Review Board) can best be described as a ‘job-site’ dispute adjudication device, typically comprising three independent and impartial persons selected by the contracting parties. The significant difference between DRB's and …Pollution Adjudication Board." In that Decision and Resolution, the Court of Appeals reversed an order of the Regional Trial Court, Quezon City, Branch 77, in Civil Case No. Q-89-2287 dismissing private respondent Solar Textile Finishing Corporation's ("Solar") petition for certiorari and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings.Hardly any companies comprehensively track their emissions, but new government regulations will require it. Everything you buy and every service you pay for pollutes. In the case o...Five members are necessary for a quorum at any regular or special meeting. The action of the majority of members present constitutes the action of the Board. Members are paid for their travel and other expenses, plus $50 per day during session and while traveling to and from meetings as provided by Idaho Code § 59-509 (h). (208) 363-2235 …Pollution Adjudication Board - Free download as Word Doc (.doc / .docx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. pabPopular pages. EMB-Pollution Adjudication Board. This website adopts the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG 2.0) as the accessibility standard for all its related web development and services.Abogado.com.ph. The Supreme Court (SC) has affirmed the P2.79-million fine imposed by the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) on Summit One Condominium Corporation (SOCC) for its failure to amply treat its wastewater. In an 8-page decision, the SC 3rd Division denied SOCC’s appeal on the Court of Appeals’ (CA) May 2014 decision to uphold the ... Pollution adjudication board, As a general rule, the adjudication of pollution cases generally pertains to the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), except in cases where the special law provides for another forum. 34 Clearly, the claim of petitioners that their immediate recourse to the regular courts is justified because the DENR is powerless to grant …, Delhi is the reigning king of polluted cities in the world. Delhi is the reigning king of polluted cities in the world, of that there is little doubt. So grimy is its air today tha..., Shell moved for dismissal of the complaint alleging that the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), not the trial court, has primary jurisdiction over pollution cases and actions for related damages and that it could not be sued pursuant to the doctrine of state immunity without the State’s consent on the basis that it merely …, Jul 3, 2020 · The Board shall assume the powers and functions of the Commission/Commissioners of the National Pollution Control Commission with respect to the adjudication of pollution cases under Republic Act 3931 and Presidential Decree 984, particularly with respect to Section 6 letters e, f, g, j, k and p of P.D. 984. , REPUBLIC v. MARCOPPER MINING CORPORATION, GR No. 137174, 2000-07-10. Facts: GONZAGA-REYES, J.: In this petition for review on certiorari, petitioner REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES through the Pollution Adjudication Board of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources seeks to annul the Decision[1] of the Court of, In Pollution Adjudication Board vs. Court of Appeals,30 we stated that the PAB is the very agency of the government with the task of determining whether the effluents of a particular industrial establishment comply with or violate applicable anti-pollution statutory and regulatory provisions.31 We also recognized its power to issue, ..., Adjudication is often described as a “pay first, argue later” mechanism for resolving disputes in the construction industry, and is designed to protect cash-flow during construction. By law, parties to a UK construction contract have the right to refer a dispute to adjudication “at any time”. When they do, the adjudicator must be ..., The Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte order directing Solar Textile Finishing Corporation to cease discharging untreated wastewater from its plant. Solar filed a petition for certiorari against the order. The regional trial court dismissed the petition but the Court of Appeals reversed, declaring the writ of execution null and …, 31 Pollution Adjudication Board Vs - Read online for free. CONSTITUTIONAL LAW DIGEST , Pollution Adjudication Board - Free download as Word Doc (.doc / .docx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. pab, WHEREFORE, the Pollution Adjudication Board RESOLVED, AS IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED, that the following guidelines should be followed in the filing of an appeal on Orders by virtue of PAB Resolution No. 1 series of 2019, to wit: SECTION I. These guidelines shall be applicable for establishments and, Ensure Attainment of an Environmental Quality that is conducive for present and future generations. Air, Water and Toxic and Hazardous Chemicals Management. Pursue Cooperation and Partnership. Environmental Impact Assessment System Implementation. Solid Waste Management. Secretariat …, METROPOLITAN WATERWORKS AND SEWERAGE SYSTEM, PETITIONER, VS. THE POLLUTION ADJUDICATION BOARD (PAB) AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT BUREAU, RESPONDENTS. SEPARATE CONCURRING OPINION. LOPEZ, J. J.: I concur in the ponencia. The actions undertaken by the water concessionaries and the surrounding circumstances of the case should merit a lesser penalty. , 31. Pollution Adjudication Board v. Court of Appeals (195 SCRA 112) - Free download as Word Doc (.doc / .docx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free., The Pollution Adjudication Board pursuant to its powers and functions under Section 19 of Executive Order No. 192, Series of 1987, RESOLVES as it is hereby RESOLVED to promulgate and adopt the following Revised Rules on Pleading, Practice and Procedure in the adjudication of pollution cases. , THE SECRETARY OF THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES ("DENR"), THE POLLUTION ADJUDICATION BOARD ("PAB"), THE REGIONAL EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT BUREAU-NATIONAL CAPITAL REGION ("EMB-NCR"), THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT BUREAU-REGION III ("EMB-REGION III"), THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENTAL M... , Air Pollution Adjudication particular hearing board. The goal is to know the board, to develop an almost intuitive awareness of the types of issues with which the various members are prepared to deal comfortably. On those issues, counsel can proceed at a fairly rapid pace, and the board members will appreciate the effort., Pollution Adjudication Board." In that Decision and Resolution, the Court of Appeals reversed an order of the Regional Trial Court, Quezon City, Branch 77, in Civil Case No. Q-89-2287 dismissing private respondent Solar Textile Finishing Corporation's ("Solar") petition for certiorari and remanded the case to the trial court for further ..., National water quality status report – this report shall identify (a) the location of water bodies, their quality, taking into account seasonal, tidal and other variations, existing and potential uses and sources of pollution per specific pollutant and pollution load assessment; (b) water quality management areas, and water …, These Boards are mostly known as Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) at the National level and State Pollution Control Board (SPCB) at the State level. The primary objective of both the Boards is to provide for the prevention, control and abatement of pollution and Acts like these empower them with …, For actual exceedance of any pollution or air quality standards under this Act or its rules and regulations, the Department, through the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB), shall impose a fine of not more than One hundred thousand pesos (P100,000) for every day of violation against the owner or operator of a stationary source until …, PAB Resolutions. Document No. Title. Date Approved. PAB Resolution No. 02 Series of 2021. Procedure on the Appeals Filed with the Pollution Adjudication …, G.R. No. 148267 August 8, 2002. SULU RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, respondent. Decisions and final orders of the Mines Adjudication Board (MAB) are appealable to the Court of Appeals under Rule 43 of the 1997 Rules of Court. Although not expressly included in the Rule, the MAB is …, The difference is that while Section 19 of EO 192 vested the Pollution Adjudication Board with the specific power to adjudicate pollution cases in general, 24 the scope of authority of LLDA to adjudicate pollution cases is limited to the Laguna Lake region as defined by RA 4850, as amended. Thus, in Laguna Lake Development Authority v., FACTS: On April 2, 2009, the Regional Office of the DENR Environmental Management Bureau-Region III (EMB-RIII) filed a complaint before the DENR’s Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) charging MWSS and its concessionaires, Maynilad and Manila Water, with failure to provide, install, operate, and maintain adequate Wastewater Treatment Facilities …, Jan 24, 2013 ... Pollution Adjudication Board fines Philex Mining over Clean Water Act Violations - Download as a PDF or view online for free., The Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) is a line bureau under the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) that is responsible for implementing environmental laws, regulations, and policies. The EMB website provides information on its programs, services, permits, and monitoring systems. It also features news, events, …, March 20, 2018. Abogado.com.ph. The Supreme Court (SC) has reinstated a P3.98-million fine imposed by the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) on the operator of Guadalupe …, March 20, 2018. Abogado.com.ph. The Supreme Court (SC) has reinstated a P3.98-million fine imposed by the Pollution Adjudication Board (PAB) on the operator of Guadalupe …, In Pollution Adjudication Board vs. Court of Appeals,30 we stated that the PAB is the very agency of the government with the task of determining whether the effluents of a particular industrial establishment comply with or violate applicable anti-pollution statutory and regulatory provisions.31 We also recognized its power to issue, ..., The nine recognized types of pollution in the modern world are air pollution, water pollution, land pollution, noise pollution, radioactive pollution, thermal pollution, light poll..., The Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte order directing Solar Textile Finishing Corporation to cease and desist from discharging untreated wastewater into a canal leading to the Tullahan-Tinejeros River. The Court of Appeals reversed the order and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings., Digest.ph. AIC Grande Tower Garnet Road Ortigas Center, Pasig City Metro Manila Philippines. Mobile No. +639451244898. The Pollution Adjudication Board issued an ex parte Order directing Solar Textile Finishing Corp to cease and desist from its operations discharging untreated wastewater in the River. When the case reached CA, CA declared that ...